The Basic Function of Practice

The Basic Function of Practice
Barry Magid

As a prelude to our discussion later this morning about the state of the zendo, I thought I would try to talk a little bit about what it is we think we're doing here. What is it that we're trying to do or create or practice? And by what criteria can we judge it, or think about improving it?

I suppose the basic function of a zendo, or of our Zen practice, is to facilitate awakening — by which we mean a realization of our essential impermanence and interconnectedness, and of how both our practice and our life outside the zendo can in some sense be seen as elaborate strategies to avoid the realities of impermanence and interdependence. In the name of — shall we just say — safety, we all try to hold on to something permanent, whether it's an inner state or an outer state of affairs that we attempt to control: whether we attempt to control our mind, or other people, or our environment. And likewise our interdependency, or vulnerability, we try to cope with either by more control of others and the environment, or by a kind of overcoming or denial of our own vulnerability and needs.

In the most basic way, as we engage in a practice of sitting, what is displayed to us moment after moment is change in our consciousness — the flow of our thoughts and feelings, in ways that seem partially under our control through discipline and attention, but at another level seem to have a life or flow of their own, independent of whatever we imagine we're doing. And there's the reality of our bodily presence, which we can control or master to some extent, but which is always going to remind us — through pain and aging and one thing after another — that the body is also not something we can ultimately control.

The other thing I think we notice about our thoughts is that our mind is not a private inner world. What we think about, what passes through our mind, is the result of our interaction with others, the result of our interaction with the world, with our place in the world, our environment. The inner is inextricably bound up with the outer. There's no clear boundary. And there's no way in which we can exert ultimate control over either the inner or the outer.

But we have this practice in which we try to maintain our attention and our presence to just this moment, one after another — what's happening, what we're experiencing. And we feel that tension between what we're willing to be present to and what we try to push away, fix, avoid, or control.

Now, when we frame it like that, it can sound as if practice is just a matter of resigning ourselves to these two unavoidable hard truths of impermanence and interdependence: there's no escaping them, so we might as well get used to it. And yet I think we also have the potential — when all those curative fantasies break down, collapse, or are let go of — to have the experience of joy or wonder or completeness at being just this moment, letting everything just be what it is. Letting ourselves be what's happening. And that can be a great release, a great relief, and a whole different way of grounding ourselves in our life, in our world, where we're able to find a kind of baseline okayness in life as it is, and in who and what we are.

So in one sense, the function of practice and the zendo is this: how well is it facilitating that practice of presence and attention, of daily zazen and of more intensive opportunities to practice?

I think there is a whole dimension of practice which we can think of as the realm of self-regulation, which, you could say, at its best provides a container for us to simply stay with our experience as it is, and not get lost in evasion, distraction, control, or fixing. That's Joko's notion of building a bigger container — a practice vehicle that lets us stay with our experience of life as it is. At a very ordinary, basic, daily level, it's creating the habit and discipline of showing up to whatever is happening during this particular hour.

And I think there's a basic way in which our whole character can be reoriented to the idea that structure and discipline and regularity and attention and care are our friends, not our obstacles. It's not something we've got to do or get through or feel constrained by. It's the tracks on which the train is running. It's what enables us to be most fully ourselves.

And here, I think, is one of the ways in which we suffer most from the absence of a physical zendo — an ongoing place of practice where that kind of discipline and regularity is enacted day in and day out, and where each of us is responsible to some degree for the maintenance of that space and that routine and that discipline. I think a big part of what traditional Zen practice provided for people was that kind of training in discipline and attention and care — paying attention to each thing as if it matters, because it all does.

Sometimes I refer to bringing all that back into our daily life as the Zen of making your bed every morning. I don't necessarily mean it literally — although probably I do. But it really does reflect the way in which we have to ask ourselves: how do we bring that kind of regularity and attention and presence and sense of mattering and care into everything that we do? We don't practice Zen in the hope that some big enlightenment experience is going to transform our lives once and for all by trickling down into them. We want our Zen practice to be something about how we conduct ourselves in the minutiae of our everyday life, in an ongoing way. And again, that's something that traditionally people learned through residential practice, so we really have to make a kind of conscious effort to figure out what is going to be the equivalent in lay life for ourselves.

Now, there's always a tension in our practice between a discipline that feels like self-regulation and the need for mutual regulation within the reality of interdependence. One kind of curative fantasy that we can fall into is a practice that we think of as solitary, independent, autonomous — something we can do entirely on our own, that is in fact going to relieve us of our vulnerability or dependency on others.

But true practice within a sangha allows us both to be dependent on one another and vulnerable to one another — to see the way in which practice is not something of our own creation, but is the result of a handed-down tradition that is co-constructed by each of us, for our own sake and for each other's sake. Very few of us are capable of sustaining this completely on our own; we need to plug in to something that is there, that we share, and which supports us.

And at the same time, sangha is a constant reminder of our vulnerability — our reactivity to the vicissitudes of the behavior of others. How we feel supported or not. Whether we get into competition with one another or not. Whether we fall into judgment of how somebody else is doing, or whether we feel judged by them about how we're doing. All those are important ways in which we have to practice with our vulnerability and interdependence. They're not just intrusions or nuisances that get in the way of practice. They are what practice is basically all about: how we are in the world with others. How are we acting to support one another? Or how much are we in a mode of always feeling that nobody else is ever quite doing what I need them to do?

It was interesting, in a way, when I was trying to think through some of this in advance, how any of this ties into what we commonly think of as the end of suffering. That's a strange — in some ways an obvious — goal for everyone to have: finding the cause and the end of suffering. Yet it doesn't end up meaning what we hope it means. In a certain way, what we come to is a realization of the futility of trying to control the uncontrollable. And it allows us to return to simply being present to life as it is, where suffering is not something that we try to overcome or banish from our lives, but something we begin to see as inseparable from our life.

And traditionally, in philosophy, suffering is not considered a problem that philosophy is supposed to overcome — except in the sense of making our peace with the reality of suffering. The real point of philosophy is to find out what is the meaning of a good life. How are we supposed to live? And the idea is not, well, let's have a life with as little suffering as possible. Is that the only meaning life has, to avoid suffering? Well, if you manage to avoid it all the time, what else are you supposed to do with yourself?

If you think of Socrates, that's an example of someone whose life is organized around trying to understand the nature of the good — trying to understand what we know and what we don't know, what we can know, how to live. And in the end, being a good man, living a kind of life that's oriented to truth, becomes much more important than avoiding suffering. When the Athenians falsely accuse him, put him on trial, and condemn him to death, a lot of his followers try to arrange a chance for him to have a jailbreak and get out of town and escape with his life. And he refuses. He doesn't try to escape — literally, the suffering of an unjust death. He says, no, my life is dedicated to behaving well in a certain way, and I have to keep doing that under all circumstances. That takes priority over avoiding suffering. How can I be a good person? That's the real project of my life.

And it was interesting for me, reading Heidegger recently. In a certain sense, Heidegger is preoccupied with authenticity and trying to figure out what that means. And to some extent, it's not being caught up in what he calls "the they" — caught up in the distractions of ordinary life. For Heidegger, it's almost as if the problem is that we don't suffer enough. For Heidegger, it's anxiety, and facing the reality of death, that is necessary to wake us up out of a slumber — the conformity of everydayness, of just going along with what the herd is doing. So there again, there's a kind of saying: the point isn't just the elimination of suffering, or how can I be happy? It's how can I find out what's meaningful in life? How do I really pay attention to what it is to be human?

And so our practice also shouldn't be thought of just in terms of: does doing this make me happier and more contented? Well, yes, obviously, in some way. I think the self-regulating, belonging part of practice can settle down our life and make us feel better. But I don't think that's all it does.

Avalokiteshvara is supposed to be awake to the sounds of the suffering of the world. Is our practice doing that? Where do compassion and right action come into our practice? That's also something that's harder to figure out — how does that get integrated into a practice like ours, a lay practice?

So I think those are some basic questions. What is it we think we're doing? How well are we doing it? What are we aiming for?

I hope we can follow up in the discussion.

Next
Next

The Perfection of Each Thing Just Being Itself