Joko’s Suffer Intelligently

Joko’s Suffer Intelligently
Barry Magid

One of the ways that Joko used to talk about practice was to say that we're learning to suffer intelligently. It wasn't immediately clear what it meant to suffer intelligently, and we generally had to approach it by looking at what it meant to suffer unintelligently — our usual way of suffering.

That meant suffering from a self-centered point of view: starting with it as my suffering, something that is happening to me, and proceeding down the usual byways of: Why are they treating me like this? Why am I not getting what I want? Why is life treating me so badly? All these ways of blaming and externalizing the cause of suffering. Or, on the other hand, internalizing it, and saying: Why did I screw up so badly? What have I done wrong? Living a life of self-reproach and regret and self-hate.

These two forms of suffering are preoccupied with the cause and the unfairness of suffering. And whether you blame others or blame yourself, for Joko this was simply a self-centered and unintelligent way to suffer — a kind of suffering that you would never learn from. That's why she called it unintelligent. In that kind of suffering, no matter how much of it you do, you learn nothing. You just dig the hole of self-centeredness deeper, the hole of resentment or self-reproach. It's just an unproductive suffering that feeds on itself.

Joko thought we needed to practice with suffering by using it as a kind of grindstone — a grindstone that's constantly spinning, and up against which we put our expectations, to have them endlessly abraded and worn down by the reality of suffering. All those expectations of being treated a certain way. All those expectations of how life was supposed to go. All those expectations of the kind of mastery or self-control or invulnerability I expect to have over myself. All the ways I expect to get an exemption from impermanence, from karma. If we make all these expectations explicit to ourselves, then when we suffer, there's the potential, she thought, to use the suffering to wear down our expectations — rather than making the suffering into a shovel with which we just dig ourselves into a deeper hole.

One of the simplest versions of that, which she taught in the zendo, was that the zendo exists as a kind of laboratory of suffering in a couple of basic ways. One is that the forms and rules and rituals of the zendo are just what they are. By and large, nobody is interested in whether it's the way you would like it to be. But it's an opportunity for you to watch your expectations of how life should organize itself for your comfort and convenience. Everybody will come to a zendo and think those rules mostly apply to everybody else, but I have an exemption. If I want to cut corners, if I don't want to do this part of it, if I don't like the chanting, if I don't like this or that — well, I don't have to do it. That whole have-it-your-way mentality was, for her, the definition of self-centeredness. And the point was to use the forms to wear that down.

The same was true of pain and sitting still. She thought that sitting with restlessness or discomfort, and even high degrees of physical pain, were ways in which we learn to suffer intelligently — to suffer an experience, a physical experience, directly, without our usual attempts at avoidance or control.

In general, we could say that our self-centeredness, as it extends out of the zendo and into the world in the face of suffering, faces two kinds of ditches: the ditch of mastery and the ditch of resignation. Either we are in a constant, endless struggle to manipulate or control our worlds to avoid suffering, or we fall into a kind of helpless despair, feeling that our agency and choice are pointless, and we just go limp in the face of suffering. Neither of those is an appropriate way to face and respond to difficulty in our lives.

I had a chance to hear a very dramatic example of an alternative to that model — an exemplar of intelligent suffering — when Congressman John Lewis spoke at Cooper Union the other night. John Lewis was at the forefront of the civil rights movement from the earliest days, when he first heard about Rosa Parks and Martin Luther King and said to himself, "That's the kind of person I want to be." He said that where he grew up in the South, everybody around him would say, "Keep your head down. Don't get in trouble." But he said that the lesson of Dr. King was that sometimes you have to get into the right kind of trouble — which in its way is its own version of suffering intelligently.

And with Dr. King, he learned the principle of nonviolent resistance, which I think is actually very profound, and hard to really understand and master. In those days, they were trying to teach people to get in trouble, to suffer intelligently, when they did things like sit in at lunch counters, or desegregate buses, or march where there were no permits. And when they did those things, they were faced with angry and often violent mobs of people who would curse at them, spit on them as they sat at the lunch counter, and, in John Lewis's case, beat them to within an inch of their lives.

Now, the hard part of nonviolent resistance was not simply a matter of sitting still and bearing it, of taking it, of non-reacting. Of course it meant that when someone spat at you, you didn't jump up and slug them. You just sat still in the face of it. But I think the really hard part, and what Dr. King emphasized, is that we're there not simply to not react, but to not hate. No matter how much you're treated as a hated other, you're there to insist that we're one people. That love and justice mean we will not divide ourselves into us and them — even when we're spat upon, even when we're beaten.

If you just think that resistance means non-reactivity, then it becomes almost a kind of stoic acceptance of pain. It can be analogous to sitting in the zendo in pain for hours and hours and just cultivating toughness: I'll take whatever they give me. I can endure anything. That's a virtue, and it'll take you so far, but it's not the virtue of non-duality. It's not the virtue of love.

But when I listened to John Lewis, I really heard a master of suffering intelligently — someone who learned to suffer without hating, without falling into that dualism.

I feel very stupid in comparison.

Previous
Previous

The Life of the Sixth Patriarch

Next
Next

A Ball Tossed on Boundless Running Water